Thirteen steps. PowerPyx lists thirteen objectives across three parts; GTABase groups the same run into seven broader ones, folding the motel trip into its break-in step and the approach and call into its final step. The run itself is identical in both. Tick each one off as you go.
Steps done:
Start by interacting with the bag in the closet of the Bayside apartment, then head to Capri, on the west side of the map. Drive yourself or take a RideMe. Go up and try the front door, then you will automatically go upstairs. The owner, Evelyn, turns down looking at the statue, it is either an incredible fake or stolen. Her colleague Benedict Halifax offers to appraise it instead. If you accept here, he gives you his watch as collateral: the Crowex Octane "Bobby Ambrose", which you can equip in Accessories, then Watches, at a wardrobe.
After leaving the shop, this optional objective lets you explore Capri together. Visiting any store or leaving town makes it go away. You are not obligated to do anything.
Only if you declined to give Halifax the statue. Call him back later to hand it over, and the mission progresses the same way. If you ignore it, it goes away at the end of Chapter 3 and you cannot complete Parts 2 and 3. It is not required for the story or for 100 percent, but you miss out on the extra rewards.
After you give Halifax the statue, he will not contact you, so return to the store. Time passes while you wait for Evelyn to leave, then get in. You have the option of breaking the front door down, but getting in quietly is the better way.
Go around the back, up the stairs, and jump across to the lower roof, then climb up and into the window above the air conditioner on the wall.
After climbing through the window, go to the door to automatically open it for Jason.
You can inspect items around the room, but the main thing is the drawer on the desk in the north corner of the room.
You now have an address for the motel directly next door.
Speak to one of the other motel residents, who points you to the upper floor room on the west side. Go up and interact with the door. After the scene, you have the option to trust him or not. In the two guides this page follows, choosing to trust him is what lets you complete Part 3.
After not hearing from Halifax again, Evelyn contacts you and says she has information. Return to the antique store to speak with her. She gives you an address of a house she believes he will be at, in the northwestern neighbourhood of the town.
After a scene, Halifax runs away and drives off in a boat, and Jason jumps on a Seashark to chase him. Follow and get close; when right by him, hold the button to jump onto his boat. He crashes the boat and starts running on foot. Swim to shore and keep chasing. He steals a golf cart and drives away; jump on the bike sitting in the yard and keep chasing. He pepper sprays Jason, then you switch to Lucia when he runs into her car. When you jump out, quickly use Focus and shoot him in the leg to stop him.
Once stopped, walk up to him so he stops running away.
Once stopped, pull out Lucia's phone and call Jason to have him come over. After Jason comes over, you have the option to Shoot or Spare Halifax now that you have the statue back; whichever you choose is up to you. After he is dealt with, you can loot around $2,500 worth of jewelry and cash from the storage container. There is also the '32 Hustler car, which you can take and sell for more money or keep for yourself.
One disagreement is still open, and this page does not hide it. A third guide, Output Lag, checked its version against no-commentary playthroughs and tells the motel choice the other way around: in its account, trusting Halifax ends the mission without the statue, and not trusting him triggers the water chase and the statue recovery, with no Shoot or Spare choice at the end. Its break-in and chase details also differ in places, and it names the motel and Maryam's full name, which neither of the two guides this page follows prints. The steps above follow PowerPyx and GTABase, which agree with each other almost word for word, and the Output Lag version is recorded here rather than silently picked over.
This page was deliberately held earlier on launch day while the two main guides disagreed completely about this mission. PowerPyx's first published version described a different job entirely, a car opened with a code, a Starfish Bay mansion and a $400 reward. PowerPyx has since corrected its walkthrough to the Capri version GTABase published, and that corrected version is what is printed above.
The guides count this mission differently. PowerPyx numbers it the 46th main mission, while GTABase numbers it 50th in chronological order. Its place is not in dispute: both guides start it right after Dealer's Choice, and both name Mami Knows Best as what follows it.
Every mission in this walkthrough is published only when two independent guides agree on its existence, its place in the order and what it asks you to do. The wording here is our own; no guide's text is copied.