LeonidaWaypoint
Service statusPlayStationXboxRockstarLive status from the official feeds →
LeonidaWaypoint
Guides Map Tracker Database News Patch Notes Known Issues About Contact
Reports · November 20, 2026

The critics gave GTA 6 a 99. Its user score is a tug of war

Official GTA VI screenshot of a crowded Vice Beach in front of a yellow lifeguard tower
Official GTA VI screenshot: the crowds of Vice Beach. The fight over the game's user score is not being waged by its verified owners, who rate it 4.84 out of 5.

Metacritic opened Grand Theft Auto VI user reviews at 2:00 PM Central on Friday, November 20, 2026. By Friday night the PlayStation 5 user score stood at 5.4 out of 10 from 29,766 ratings, split almost exactly in half, 47 percent positive and 46 percent negative, while the Xbox score read 4.9. Verified owners rate the same game 4.84 out of 5 on the PlayStation Store from about 170,000 ratings. What the fight is made of, why the two numbers disagree, and what happens next.

Published November 20, 2026 · Last checked November 20, 2026, 9:35 PM CentralLeonida Waypoint desk5 min read

What happened

Metacritic opened Grand Theft Auto VI to user reviews at 2:00 PM Central on Friday, November 20, 2026, two days after the critic embargo lifted and one day after launch. By Friday night, at this report's last check at 9:35 PM Central, the PlayStation 5 user score stood at 5.4 out of 10, labeled "Mixed or Average", from 29,766 ratings. The Xbox Series X user score read 4.9 out of 10, labeled "Generally Unfavorable", on a page carrying 1,347 written user reviews. Every figure in this report is stamped as of Friday night, November 20, 2026, because the score is still moving hourly.

It has swung all day as the ratings poured in. Fextralife tracked the PlayStation 5 score as low as 3.7 in the first hours after the ballot opened. Keengamer caught it at 5.1 from about 10,000 ratings, Notebookcheck at 5.2 from 13,192 ratings, and by Friday night it had climbed to the 5.4 recorded above. The critic score on the same page never moved: a Metascore of 99 from 152 critic reviews, 100 percent of them positive.

What the split actually looks like

The 5.4 is not a consensus, and Metacritic's own breakdown proves it. Of those 29,766 PlayStation 5 ratings, 47 percent are positive (13,867 ratings), 8 percent are mixed (2,254) and 46 percent are negative (13,645). Almost half the pool rates the game at the top of the scale and almost half rates it at the bottom. The average sits in the middle because the two sides cancel each other out, not because players agree the game is mediocre.

The pool is an open ballot. Metacritic asks only for an email registration before anyone can rate a game; no purchase is required (Notebookcheck, Push Square). The PlayStation Store, by contrast, only accepts ratings from accounts that own the game. The Metacritic pool visibly contains people who have not played GTA VI, on both sides of the fight: one 10 out of 10 PlayStation 5 review, from a user named SegTindo, reads "Haven't played the game just helping out the positive crowd cause review bombing a game is stupid." Zero scores posted to drag the average down sit opposite it. Treat the user score as a measure of the argument, not of the audience.

This is also the second time Metacritic has had to police this game's user scores. Before launch, the site removed fake user ratings, including an early 6.5 built on about five ratings, and temporarily blocked submissions around November 17 (VGC, reporting Keengamer, Fextralife and PlanetGTA6). No user score dated before Friday's 2:00 PM Central opening was real.

The owners' score tells a different story

Where a rating requires owning the game, the picture sits far closer to the critics. Push Square reports the PlayStation Store rating at 4.84 out of 5 from about 170,000 owner ratings on Friday night; ComicBook puts it at 4.85 from more than 162,000. Before user reviews opened, the same store read 4.87 out of 5 from about 94,000 ratings. The owner pool has nearly doubled since then, and the score has eased by 0.03.

On Xbox, the store shows 5 out of 5 stars from more than 22,000 reviews (ComicBook), a coarser measure than PlayStation's, but pointing the same way: the people who bought the game are rating it near the top of the scale, broadly in line with the critics' 99 rather than with the open ballot's 5.4.

What it means while you play

Read the 5.4 as weather, not as a verdict. Real criticism does exist inside the noise, repeated across the substantive written reviews: the 30fps performance and frame drops, slow story pacing, the life-sim and relationship mechanics, and bugs. Those are live complaints from people playing the game, and they rhyme with the caveats critics raised inside their 99. This site's reviews page collects the critic scores with their sources, and our launch reviews report covers what the reviewers themselves said.

The honest summary is three numbers, not one: critics 99, verified owners 4.84 out of 5, and an unverified user score being pulled apart by two campaigns at once. If the 5.4 gets quoted at you this weekend, the missing context is the 47-to-46 split underneath it.

What happens next

Expect the score to keep moving for days as ratings accumulate, and expect the rating count itself to move if Metacritic moderates this wave the way it handled the pre-launch one. As of Friday night there has been no official comment on the current wave from Rockstar, Take-Two or Metacritic (PlanetGTA6). If the score settles, or any of the three comments, this report updates, and the reviews page keeps tracking the critic side as its counts grow.

Sources

  • Metacritic, Grand Theft Auto VI (PlayStation 5) game page and PlayStation 5 user reviews page, read directly on November 20, 2026 at 9:35 PM Central: metacritic.com. The user score of 5.4, the 29,766 ratings, the 47 percent positive (13,867), 8 percent mixed (2,254) and 46 percent negative (13,645) split, the Metascore of 99 from 152 critic reviews, and the SegTindo review quoted in this report.
  • Metacritic, Grand Theft Auto VI (Xbox Series X) user reviews page, read directly the same night: the user score of 4.9 and the 1,347 written user reviews.
  • Push Square, GTA VI user score coverage (published November 20, 2026): the PlayStation Store rating of 4.84 out of 5 from about 170,000 reviews, and Metacritic's email-only registration requirement.
  • ComicBook, GTA VI coverage (published November 20, 2026): the PlayStation Store at 4.85 from more than 162,000 reviews, and the Xbox Store at 5 out of 5 stars from more than 22,000 reviews.
  • Notebookcheck, GTA VI user score coverage (published November 20, 2026): the score at 5.2 from 13,192 ratings earlier in the day, and the email-only registration requirement.
  • Keengamer, GTA VI user score coverage (published November 20, 2026): the score at 5.1 from about 10,000 ratings.
  • Fextralife, GTA VI user score coverage (published November 20, 2026): the score dipping as low as 3.7 in the first hours after user reviews opened.
  • VGC, reporting Keengamer, Fextralife and PlanetGTA6 (November 2026): Metacritic removed the fake pre-launch user ratings for GTA VI and temporarily blocked submissions around November 17, 2026.
  • PlanetGTA6 (November 20, 2026): no official comment from Rockstar, Take-Two or Metacritic on the current wave of user scores.
Official GTA VI screenshot of the Vice City skyline at night, the ferris wheel lit above the bay
ReviewsUpdated at launch

Reviews

The living scores page: Metacritic 99, OpenCritic 99, the named scores with their sources, and re-checks as the counts grow.

See the reviews page →